Methodology
This page explains what the site does, and more importantly, what it does NOT do. Trust comes from transparency, not claims.
1. The system never says “confirmed”
A fully automated system cannot claim verification. This site only reports which source said what. The highest label is “reported by multiple independent sources”. The words “confirmed” or “verified” never appear on this site in any language.
2. Labels and their meanings
- Official statement
A formal statement by WHO, CDC, ECDC or a government body. Research centres (CIDRAP, ProMED) do not qualify; they are independent organisations.
- Reported by multiple independent sources
Two or more INDEPENDENT source groups reported the same event. This does not mean “confirmed”; it means “many independent sources report the same thing”.
- Reported by a single source
Only one independence group reported it. It may be true, but there is no independent corroboration yet.
- Unverified claim
A claim from Telegram channels or unregistered publishers. Not counted as news in the main feed.
- Conflicting reports
Conflicting claims about the same event (e.g. officials say “none” while independent sources report a “suspected case”). This comparison is experimental.
3. Independence groups: the most important rule
Sources under the same ownership umbrella count as ONE source. If TASS, RIA, RT and Sputnik all publish the same story, the independent source count is 1. This is the core protection against “showing one source as many”.
Groups in use
4. How is the trust score computed?
trust = tier_base
+ min(independent_group_count - 1, 4) * 6
+ state_control_penalty // kremlin: -8, ru-gov: -5Scores are set MANUALLY and versioned; nothing is learned automatically. Scores are not shown as numbers in the UI (to avoid a false sense of precision); tier (T1–T5) and source name are shown instead.
5. Limits and known weaknesses
- Event clustering relies on headline and summary similarity; the same event in different languages may sometimes cluster separately.
- Contradiction detection is experimental and being calibrated at the claim level; it is currently conservative and stays silent rather than risk false positives.
- Only non-Turkish sources (English/Russian) are translated in the TR view; translation is machine translation and this is noted in the event detail. The original headline always remains visible (a "read original" line on the card, and below the title in the detail view); a translation that fails validation is never shown; the original headline is shown instead.
- Some sources (Rospotrebnadzor, Novaya Gazeta Europe) are unreachable directly and are fetched via an aggregator.
- Source trust scores are editorial decisions; version changes are recorded transparently.
- Figures are NOT extracted from text automatically. Naive extraction was measured and failed: “a 28-year-old researcher died” produced “28 deaths”, and “quarantines 200 people” produced “200 deaths”. Showing a wrong number is worse than showing none. So only figures that appear in the source’s own sentence and are manually verified are shown; a record that cannot be linked is never displayed.
- Keyword scanning covers English, Turkish and Russian only; content in other languages may be missed.
6. Sources being monitored
45 sources · 40 healthy · 4 STALE · 1 FAILED
- T1WHO · Disease Outbreak NewsWHO ailesiWHO RSS feed’i kaldırıldı (404, Eki 2026). Şimdilik Google News üzerinden; F1’de doğrudan HTML parse eklenecek.
- T1WHO Avrupa Bölge OfisiWHO ailesi
- T1ECDC · Avrupa Hastalık Önleme ve Kontrol MerkeziECDCRSS yok (404). Google News + F1’de HTML parse.
- T1US CDC · PlagueUS CDC
- T1CIDRAP (University of Minnesota)CIDRAP (Minnesota Üniv.)ÖLÇÜLDÜ: /rss.xml canlı görünüyor ama en yeni öğesi Kas 2022 → BAYAT. RSS kullanılmıyor. Bayat-feed tespitinin gerekliliğinin kanıtı.
- T1ProMED-mail (ISID)ProMED-mail (ISID)RSS yok (404). Salgın erken uyarıda altın standart; F1’de arşiv HTML parse.
- T1ReliefWeb (UN OCHA)BM kuruluşlarıRSS çalışıyor. Tüm dünya güncellemelerini verir → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2ReutersReuters
- T2Associated PressAssociated Press
- T2BBC NewsBBCGoogle News yerine DOĞRUDAN RSS (08 Eki 2026): gerçek makale linki + kaynağın kendi özeti geliyor. Genel dünya akışı → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2Al JazeeraAl JazeeraGoogle News yerine DOĞRUDAN RSS (08 Eki 2026): gerçek makale linki + kaynağın kendi özeti. Genel akış → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2EuronewsEuronewsGoogle News yerine DOĞRUDAN RSS (08 Eki 2026): gerçek makale linki + kaynak özeti. Genel akış → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2The GuardianThe GuardianDoğrudan RSS (08 Eki 2026). Önceden yalnızca keşif (discovery) ile geliyordu, kaynak olarak taranmıyordu. Genel dünya akışı → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2NBC NewsNBC NewsDoğrudan RSS (08 Eki 2026). Önceden yalnızca keşif ile geliyordu. Genel haber akışı → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2AxiosAxiosDoğrudan RSS (08 Eki 2026, 100 öğe). Genel akış → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T2The New York TimesThe New York Times
- T2The Washington PostThe Washington Post
- T2NPRNPR
- T2PBS NewsHourPBS NewsHour
- T2Le MondeLe Monde
- T2ABC NewsABC News
- T2CNBCCNBC
- T2The AtlanticThe Atlantic
- T2Sky NewsSky News
- T2Global NewsGlobal News
- T2The Hillthehill
- T2VoxVox
- T2NewsweekNewsweek
- T2New York PostNew York Post
- T2Fox NewsFox News
- T2ScienceScience
- T2The BMJThe BMJHakemli dergi; bilimsel yorum katmanı.
- T3RospotrebnadzorRus resmi devlet kurumlarıÖLÇÜLDÜ: doğrudan erişim Türkiye’den başarısız (HTTP 000). Google News önbelleği üzerinden; proxy yolu F1’de eklenecek.
- T3Rusya Sağlık BakanlığıRus resmi devlet kurumları
- T3TASSKremlin yanlısı devlet medyası (TASS/RIA/RT/Sputnik)RSS çalışıyor (100 öğe) ama genel haber akışı → relevance filtresi zorunlu.
- T3RIA NovostiKremlin yanlısı devlet medyası (TASS/RIA/RT/Sputnik)
- T3InterfaxKremlin yanlısı devlet medyası (TASS/RIA/RT/Sputnik)Görece daha bağımsız ama muhafazakâr varsayımla aynı çatı grubunda sayılır.
- T4MeduzaMeduzaRSS çalışıyor (30 öğe). Letonya merkezli.
- T4RFE/RL (Sibirya.Realities)RFE/RLÖLÇÜLDÜ: /api/zrqiteuuir ve /api/zmgqimmitm 0 öğe döndürüyor; /api/ 20 öğe ile çalışıyor. Bölgesel muhabir ağı güçlü; Irkutsk olayını ilk bildiren kaynaklardan.
- T4The Moscow TimesThe Moscow TimesRSS çalışıyor (50 öğe). Amsterdam merkezli.
- T4Novaya Gazeta EuropeNovaya Gazeta EuropeÖLÇÜLDÜ: /rss 404, /feed 521, /rss.xml 403 → RSS erişilemiyor. Google News üzerinden alınıyor.
- T5Genel keşif (çok dilli Google News)Toplayıcı (Google News / GDELT)Yeni yayıncı keşfi için. Orijinal yayıncı tanınıyorsa onun tier’ı uygulanır; tanınmıyorsa T5 kalır.
- T5Keşif · TürkçeToplayıcı (Google News / GDELT)
- T5Telegram · AstraTelegram sosyal sinyalYalnızca "doğrulanmamış iddia" katmanı. Ana akışta tek başına haber sayılmaz.
- T5Telegram · ShotTelegram sosyal sinyal
7. Last update
Data refreshes every 5–10 minutes. Stale feeds are detected: if a source responds but its content is old, it is flagged as “STALE” and shown in the panel.
Last scan: